This page details the specific criteria we use when reviewing ear plugs. Each criterion has a weight that contributes to the overall score. Learn more about how our scoring system works.

Scoring Overview

Each criterion below is weighted as a percentage of the total score. We evaluate each product on a scale of 1 to 5 for every criterion, then multiply by the weight to calculate the final rating.

Core functionality (12%)

Does it meaningfully reduce unwanted noise? I’m checking whether it works for sleep, travel, work or concentration. I’m evaluating if the Noise Reduction Rating is appropriate for travel use. I’m testing whether it blocks the right frequencies, especially low-frequency engine hum on planes. Ear plugs must provide measurable relief from disruptive noise. The question is whether this product solves the travel noise problem it was designed to fix.

Materials & build quality (9%)

This is the you know when you feel it category, but for ear plugs I’m focusing on plug-specific materials. I’m evaluating foam quality, comparing memory foam versus cheap polyfoam. For reusable plugs, I’m checking silicone or TPE durability. I’m testing hypoallergenic and skin-safe materials since these sit inside your ear canal. I’m assessing seamless construction for comfort and hygiene. For filtered acoustic plugs, I’m evaluating filter quality. Materials matter because plugs that irritate or fail quickly become unusable.

Comfort & fit (13%)

This is one of the two most important categories for ear plugs. I’m evaluating long-term comfort during flights or overnight sleep. I’m checking pressure inside the ear canal to see if it causes discomfort. I’m testing ergonomic shape and whether it adapts to different ear sizes. I’m assessing whether there’s soreness after extended use. I’m checking if it stays in place during movement or side-sleeping. Fit determines whether a plug actually works. If it hurts or falls out, nothing else matters.

Noise reduction effectiveness (15%)

This is the defining metric of ear plugs. I’m evaluating real-world performance versus advertised NRR or SNR ratings. I’m testing low-frequency noise reduction for planes, buses and snores. I’m checking high-frequency dampening. I’m assessing consistency of seal because a broken seal means zero protection. For high-end reusable plugs, I’m evaluating filter quality. I’m also checking that there’s no excessive isolation that causes discomfort or heartbeat noise. Effectiveness varies significantly by plug style, so I’m scoring accordingly.

Pressure equalization (8%)

This is critical for airplane use. I’m evaluating whether the plug helps reduce cabin pressure discomfort. For filtered plugs, I’m testing whether they prevent ear popping during ascent and descent. I’m checking comfort during pressure changes. This matters especially for travelers prone to ear pressure issues. Some plugs make flights worse while others help equalize pressure.

Seal consistency & movement stability (8%)

Many plugs fail this silently. I’m checking whether the plug stays sealed when turning or shifting in sleep. I’m testing whether it gradually slips out during the night. I’m evaluating whether the seal weakens with repeated reuse. I’m assessing movement stability during side-sleeping. A plug that loses its seal halfway through a flight defeats the purpose.

Packability & footprint (8%)

Ear plugs are tiny, but case quality makes a huge difference. I’m evaluating case quality and size. I’m testing portability on keychains or in pockets. I’m checking whether pairs stay together and don’t get lost in a bag. I’m assessing organization since losing one plug means losing the pair. A great case can make or break everyday usability.

Ease of use (9%)

Usability matters most when you’re tired and boarding a flight. I’m evaluating how quickly they can be inserted. I’m checking clear left and right orientation if applicable. I’m testing ease of achieving a proper seal. For filter plugs, I’m assessing complexity with multiple tips and stems. I’m evaluating removal comfort to see if there’s painful suction or risk of slipping deep into ear canals. The best plugs work immediately without a learning curve.

Durability & resilience (6%)

Durability varies dramatically by plug type. For foam plugs, I’m evaluating recovery longevity and checking for early crumbling or deforming. For silicone plugs, I’m testing elasticity retention over time. For filtered plugs, I’m checking filter endurance and whether they block over time. I’m assessing case durability. I’m also evaluating resistance to dirt and pocket debris. Reusable plugs should survive months or years of use.

Ease of maintenance & cleaning (8%)

This is critical for reusable plugs. I’m evaluating washability with soap, water or specialized cleaners. I’m testing dry-time speed since you need plugs ready quickly. I’m checking debris resistance. For high-end filtered plugs, I’m assessing filter maintenance requirements. I’m evaluating hygiene friendliness. Foam plugs are disposable, but silicone and filtered plugs must clean easily or they become unusable.

Versatility across environments (6%)

Great ear plugs adapt to many noise environments. I’m evaluating performance on planes, buses and trains. I’m testing effectiveness in noisy hotels or hostels. I’m checking sleeping at home use. I’m assessing work performance in cafés or shared offices. For filtered models, I’m testing concert or loud event compatibility. I’m also checking compatibility with side-sleeping, hats or travel pillows. The question is how well it handles different noise scenarios.

Overall value for price (2%)

Where does this land on price versus what you’re actually getting? I’m evaluating effectiveness and longevity versus price. I’m testing whether disposable foam plugs justify their cost per use. I’m checking whether reusable plugs deliver long-term value. Build quality, noise reduction performance and durability all factor into whether it’s worth the cost.

Here are our reviews of ear plugs that use these scoring criteria:

Where to go next

🎒 Found the right gear?

We research and test the gear we recommend, so you can pack with confidence. If our suggestions improved your gear picks, treating us to a coffee keeps the reviews coming.

Help us test more gear