This page details the specific criteria we use when reviewing dopp kits. Each criterion has a weight that contributes to the overall score. Learn more about how our scoring system works.

Scoring Overview

Each criterion below is weighted as a percentage of the total score. We evaluate each product on a scale of 1 to 5 for every criterion, then multiply by the weight to calculate the final rating.

Core functionality (11%)

Does it store and stabilize liquids, grooming tools and toiletries? Does it prevent spills from reaching clothing? Does it keep items upright and visible? Does it improve daily bathroom routines while traveling? A dopp kit exists to protect the rest of your luggage from your toiletries.

Materials & build quality (11%)

This is the you know when you feel it category. I’m evaluating water-resistant or waterproof fabrics that survive toothpaste, shampoo and wet counters. I’m checking easy-wipe interior linings like TPU, PU or silicone-coated materials. I’m testing corrosion-resistant zippers that handle moisture without failing. I’m assessing reinforced seams for weight and pressure. I’m also evaluating shape retention for structured dopp kits. Materials must survive bathroom environments.

Organization & access speed (13%)

Speed and layout matter most when you’re half-awake in a hotel bathroom. I’m evaluating mesh pockets for visibility so you can see what’s inside. I’m checking elastic loops for toothbrushes, razors and deodorant. I’m testing interior separation for wet and dry items. I’m comparing clamshell versus wide-mouth top access styles. I’m evaluating hanging hook usability for kits that offer it. I’m also assessing whether you can access items without everything spilling out. The question is how fast you can grab what you need.

Packability & footprint (9%)

Does it fit easily into luggage without wasting space? I’m testing compressibility when partially filled. I’m comparing structured versus soft-sided tradeoffs. I’m evaluating bulk added by internal organization. I’m checking whether it fits inside carry-on allowances, personal item pockets or backpacks. I’m also assessing weight efficiency relative to capacity. Dopp kits should pack flat when needed but still hold their shape in use.

Ease of use (9%)

Dopp kits must excel in cramped, slippery environments. I’m evaluating how well it sits on small counters. I’m testing stability when opened. I’m checking whether it’s easy to grab and open with wet hands. I’m assessing clear internal visibility. I’m also evaluating hook deployment speed for hanging kits. The question is whether the learning curve is minimal and the ergonomics work in tight hotel bathrooms.

Durability & resilience (9%)

Toiletry items are heavy, sharp and messy. Durability is essential. I’m evaluating resistance to bathroom moisture. I’m testing stress from heavy liquids. I’m checking zipper strength when overstuffed. I’m assessing lining durability against leaks. I’m also evaluating long-term resistance to mildew or odor. The question is whether it handles real-world abuse without failing.

Ease of maintenance & cleaning (11%)

This is one of the most important categories for dopp kits. I’m evaluating wipe-clean interior performance. I’m testing mold and mildew resistance. I’m checking drainage capability for waterproof bags. I’m assessing quick air-drying behavior. I’m also evaluating lining compatibility with spilled products like shampoo, lotion and toothpaste. Cleaning should be simple, not a chore.

Leak protection (10%)

Leak protection is the defining feature of a good dopp kit. I’m evaluating ability to contain internal liquid leaks. I’m testing water resistance against external moisture like wet counters. I’m checking sturdy zippers that prevent seepage. I’m assessing internal coatings that prevent stains and odors. The question is whether your toiletries stay contained and your luggage stays dry.

Moisture management (6%)

This matters for travelers who shower, pack and leave within minutes. I’m evaluating ventilation to prevent mildew. I’m testing quick-dry panels. I’m comparing breathable versus waterproof tradeoffs. I’m assessing protection from steamy environments. The question is whether the kit handles moisture without trapping it inside.

Versatility across trip types (6%)

A good dopp kit handles unpredictable bathroom environments. I’m evaluating whether it works for quick overnight stays, long trips, gym use and carry-on travel. I’m testing adaptable layout for different toiletry setups. I’m comparing hanging versus countertop versatility. I’m checking whether it works in hotels, hostels, airports and campgrounds. The question is how well it adapts to your actual travel patterns.

Overall value for price (6%)

Where does this land on price versus what you’re actually getting? I’m evaluating durability and utility versus price. I’m testing whether the build quality matches the cost. I’m checking warranty coverage and repair options. Build quality, leak protection, durability and warranty all factor into whether it’s worth the cost.

Here are our reviews of dopp kits that use these scoring criteria:

Where to go next

🎒 Found the right gear?

We research and test the gear we recommend, so you can pack with confidence. If our suggestions improved your gear picks, treating us to a coffee keeps the reviews coming.

Help us test more gear