This page details the specific criteria we use when reviewing travel shorts. Each criterion has a weight that contributes to the overall score. Learn more about how our scoring system works.

Scoring Overview

Each criterion below is weighted as a percentage of the total score. We evaluate each product on a scale of 1 to 5 for every criterion, then multiply by the weight to calculate the final rating.

Comfort against skin (13%)

Shorts must feel good against bare skin. I’m evaluating interior softness, especially for synthetic fabrics that can feel rough. I’m checking seam comfort at the inner thigh since chafe risk is real when walking. I’m testing waistband comfort, comparing elastic versus hybrid versus fixed designs. If the shorts include a liner, I’m evaluating how that feels against skin. Comfort is extremely important for travel shorts since you’re wearing them in hot weather with minimal layers underneath.

Fit, mobility & sizing accuracy (11%)

Whether the piece lines up with the size chart and accommodates different builds. I’m evaluating true waist fit since elastic and drawstring combos vary widely. I’m checking thigh room, comparing athletic thigh cuts versus straight cuts. I’m testing rise accuracy because low rise feels uncomfortable when walking. I’m assessing hem opening fit since too tight restricts movement and too loose looks sloppy. I’m also checking inseam length usability, whether that’s 5 inches, 7 inches or 9 inches depending on the target audience. Shorts depend heavily on silhouette and thigh fit.

Materials, durability & easy care (9%)

Travel shorts must handle sweat, heat and quick wash cycles. I’m evaluating fiber blend and how it performs in real travel. I’m testing dry time after washing or getting wet, which is very important for summer travel. I’m checking odor resistance, especially for synthetics that can hold smells. I’m assessing pilling resistance over time. I’m testing saltwater and pool resistance as a bonus if they can double as hybrid swim shorts. I’m also evaluating color retention under UV exposure. We’re generous with care since we typically don’t put things in the dryer, but the care requirements still factor into the score.

Durability & abrasion resistance (8%)

Shorts suffer from specific wear patterns that deserve their own scoring slot. I’m evaluating inner thigh abrasion resistance since that’s a common failure point. I’m checking seat wear from benches, stone steps and airport seats. I’m testing stretch seam stress durability. I’m assessing pocket stress from phones and keys. Most travel short failures occur in these areas, so this gets scored separately from materials quality.

Breathability & moisture management (11%)

This is one of the biggest differentiators in summer apparel. I’m evaluating airflow in hot and humid climates. I’m testing moisture wicking performance on the waistband and thighs. I’m checking clinginess when sweaty since some fabrics stick to your legs. This separates good technical fabrics from basic blends. The question is how the fabric vents during a city walk or a hike without trapping heat and moisture.

Temperature regulation (9%)

Shorts must thrive in variable summer conditions. I’m evaluating cool morning versus hot afternoon performance. I’m testing wind versus airflow balance. I’m checking comfort while sitting on hot surfaces like planes, trains and benches. The question is whether these shorts keep you comfortable from chilly mornings to warm afternoons while handling temperature shifts throughout the day.

Stretch, mobility & shape retention (8%)

This is critical for shorts. Joggers and pants sag, but shorts bag or flare. I’m checking seat sagging resistance. I’m testing thigh stretch for walking and hiking. I’m evaluating elastic recovery after a hot sweaty day. I’m assessing whether the hem bags or flares out. The question is whether the shorts return to form after a long day of wear without losing their shape.

Pocket function & travel security (9%)

This is very important for warm weather travel. I’m evaluating pocket depth and angle to see if phones stay in during movement. I’m checking zippered pockets for passport and security storage. I’m testing bounce resistance when walking. I’m assessing back pocket usability. I’m also evaluating item visibility, checking if phone outlines show through the fabric. Pocket practicality can make or break shorts in travel contexts.

Wrinkle resistance & packability (8%)

I’m evaluating packing cube compression behavior. I’m testing fold versus roll performance. I’m checking wrinkle recovery speed after unpacking. I’m assessing fabric drape after compression. I’m also testing packability and weight since ultra-light versus mid-weight fabrics affect bulk in packing cubes. Lightweight fabrics wrinkle differently than heavier ones, and this matters for summer travelers who need dry later and pack earlier convenience.

Styling versatility (9%)

Many travel shorts are too gym-looking. This category helps differentiate. I’m evaluating travel to casual to smart casual adaptability. I’m testing compatibility with sneakers, sandals and slip-ons. I’m checking whether the silhouette is clean and minimal, not overly sporty unless it’s intentionally athletic travel shorts. I’m assessing branding visibility. The question is whether these shorts work across different travel scenarios without looking like gym shorts or swim trunks.

Overall value for price (6%)

Where does this land on price versus what you’re actually getting? I’m evaluating longevity versus lightweight fabric trade-offs. I’m testing seasonal versatility to see if they’re hot weather only or multi-use. I’m comparing fabric quality versus cost. I’m assessing competitiveness versus other travel shorts in the category. Build quality, performance and warranty all factor into whether it’s worth the cost.

Here are our reviews of travel shorts that use these scoring criteria:

Where to go next

🎒 Found the right gear?

We research and test the gear we recommend, so you can pack with confidence. If our suggestions improved your gear picks, treating us to a coffee keeps the reviews coming.

Help us test more gear