This page details the specific criteria we use when reviewing tote bags. Each criterion has a weight that contributes to the overall score. Learn more about how our scoring system works.

Scoring Overview

Each criterion below is weighted as a percentage of the total score. We evaluate each product on a scale of 1 to 5 for every criterion, then multiply by the weight to calculate the final rating.

Carry comfort & fit (12%)

Totes carry differently from backpacks, so I’m checking handle drop length for under-arm versus hand-carry comfort. I’m evaluating shoulder strap width and padding, plus whether straps slip or grip. I’m testing balance with tech weight loaded up, meaning laptop plus charger plus water bottle. If there’s a crossbody option, I’m seeing how it performs. Handles make or break comfort for totes, so this category matters more here than it does for backpacks.

Organization & access speed (12%)

Tech totes live or die by easy access. I’m checking top closure style, whether that’s zipper, magnetic, snap or open-top. I’m looking at internal compartment structure like laptop sleeve placement, bottle pocket location and admin panel organization. I’m testing quick-access performance for keys and phone. I’m evaluating desk usability, meaning does it flop wide open or stay structured when you need to grab something fast. Most people choose totes for fast access, so this is a top-tier criterion.

Laptop & tech protection (10%)

This is important for this category. I’m checking laptop sleeve rigidity and whether it actually protects your device. I’m testing suspension from the base, meaning does the laptop sit on the bottom or float above it. I’m evaluating tech pocket accessibility and whether charger plus tech organization exists. Most tech totes fail here. They look good but lack real protection.

Materials & build quality (10%)

I’m checking handle construction, whether that’s leather, rolled handles or reinforced stitching. I’m evaluating interior lining durability, since light-colored linings stain quickly. I’m testing bag structure, meaning structured versus slouchy, and how that affects laptop safety. I’m looking at base panel durability, since totes sit on the ground constantly. Premium totes differentiate themselves through materials and craftsmanship.

Structure & self-standing ability (8%)

This is critical for desk and floor use. I’m testing whether the tote stands upright on its own or collapses when empty. I’m checking if the structure holds when partially loaded. I’m evaluating how the base panel supports the bag’s weight distribution. A tote that can’t stand on its own becomes frustrating fast when you’re trying to pack it or grab something from it.

Weather resistance (8%)

I’m comparing zippered top versus open-top protection. I’m testing fabric water repellency and how quickly water beads off. I’m checking bottom panel wet-ground resistance, since totes spend time on damp surfaces. I’m evaluating hardware corrosion resistance for zippers and buckles exposed to rain. Open-top totes score lower here unless they have internal weather flaps or zippers.

Security & closure confidence (10%)

This is very important for totes, since many are open-top. I’m checking zippered closure availability and whether it’s full-coverage or partial. I’m testing magnetic or snap closure strength and whether they hold under load. I’m evaluating pickpocket defense, meaning does the bag naturally fold inward or stay wide open. I’m checking hidden internal pocket usefulness and placement.

Compressibility & travel packing ease (8%)

Totes rarely nest, so I’m testing compressibility and travel packing ease instead. I’m checking whether it packs flat in a suitcase without taking up too much space. I’m testing if it stands upright for easy packing when in use. I’m evaluating whether it collapses without damaging structure. This is the correct metric for tote travel performance.

Versatility for work & travel (12%)

I’m checking work readiness, meaning does it fit laptop, lunch and notebooks comfortably. I’m testing everyday carry functionality and whether it handles daily essentials without feeling overstuffed. I’m evaluating travel usability, including airport-friendly sizing, trolley sleeve performance and top closure security. I’m testing style adaptability for professional and casual settings.

Overall value for price (8%)

Where the bag lands on price versus performance, build quality and warranty coverage. Premium totes can be heavy even empty, so I’m weighing whether the materials justify the cost. I’m comparing durability expectations against actual construction quality.

Here are our reviews of tote bags that use these scoring criteria:

Where to go next

🎒 Found the right gear?

We research and test the gear we recommend, so you can pack with confidence. If our suggestions improved your gear picks, treating us to a coffee keeps the reviews coming.

Help us test more gear